What is an IPO? Hidden Risks Most First-Time Investors Overlook

Companies use an IPO (Initial Public Offering) to go from private to public by selling shares to institutional and retail investors. The process takes more than six months to complete. Companies must file extensive regulatory documents and pay hefty banking and legal fees. Many businesses actually struggle after going public, and some even shut down within a few years.

Most first-time investors miss several hidden risks when they jump into IPO investments. The complex valuation process and the challenge of getting shares in popular offerings can catch them off guard. This piece will help you spot common IPO investment traps, whether you’re planning your first IPO investment or just want to learn more about the stock market.

Also Read: How to Invest in Public Provident Fund: A Comprehensive Guide to Secure Your Future

What is an IPO in Stock Market Terms

The Bank of North America launched America’s first IPO back in 1783. IPOs have changed substantially since those early days, and they reached a new milestone when Saudi Aramco raised $29.4 billion in 2019. The basic principle stays the same though.

A company’s experience of going public starts with an Initial Public Offering (IPO). This process lets a company sell shares of its stock to institutional and retail investors for the first time ^[1]. Companies can raise substantial capital this way to expand, reduce debt, or fund new initiatives ^[1].

Private vs Public Company Differences

Private companies have a small group of shareholders that includes founders, family members, and professional investors like venture capitalists ^[1]. On top of that, these companies face fewer regulations and you retain control over operations ^[2].

Private organizations need to follow simple laws and statutes, while public companies must comply with detailed SEC oversight regulations ^[3]. Public companies also share quarterly earnings reports and provide detailed financial information to shareholders ^[2]. Investors use this transparency to make smart decisions about buying or selling shares.

The difference between private and public entities goes beyond following regulations. Public companies are accountable to many shareholders and need more resources for legal and accounting oversight ^[3]. Even with these challenges, public markets are a great way to get capital, making them attractive for growing businesses ^[3].

How Companies Raise Money Through IPOs

Companies need several steps to raise capital through IPOs. They pick investment banks as underwriters to handle securities registration and share distribution ^[4]. These underwriters help set the original offering price through detailed research ^[1].

Companies must file detailed registration statements with the SEC before trading starts ^[5]. This documentation has:

• Financial statements and performance metrics
• Background information about management
• Details about insider holdings
• Potential legal challenges
• The proposed ticker symbol

The underwriting process costs between 4% to 7% of the gross IPO proceeds ^[6]. Companies also spend $1 million to $1.9 million each year to stay public ^[6].

After approval, companies can raise money in different ways. The primary offering sends money straight from investors to the company, while secondary offerings let early private investors sell their holdings ^[7]. This flexibility helps companies achieve different goals, from expanding operations to paying off debt ^[8].

Companies that succeed with IPOs often run their business like public companies before going public ^[5]. This preparation helps them handle increased scrutiny and meet their ongoing obligations. Smart planning and execution help companies discover the full potential of raising capital while streamlining processes ^[5].

The IPO Process Timeline

A company’s trip from private to public status follows a well-laid-out timeline. This process usually takes six to nine months ^[9]. Companies need to direct themselves through several crucial phases to make their market debut successful.

Selecting Investment Banks

Companies start by choosing investment banks as underwriters. They review potential partners based on:

• Their industry expertise and reputation
• Success rates with previous IPOs
• Quality of investment research
• Knowing how to attract investors through syndication ^[10]

Selected banks compete in a “bake-off” where they showcase detailed pitch books. These books outline deal reviews, risks, and suggested valuations ^[10]. The lead underwriter, called the book runner, manages the whole ordeal while co-managers help with specific tasks ^[11].

Filing SEC Registration

The company builds a team of experts after selecting underwriters. This team includes lawyers, certified public accountants, and SEC specialists ^[10]. They prepare the S-1 registration statement, a detailed document that contains:

• Historical financial statements
• Company’s background information
• Risk factors
• Insider holdings
• Proposed ticker symbol ^[12]

The SEC usually finishes its original review within 27 calendar days ^[13]. Companies then respond to SEC comments and file amendments. Each review cycle takes about two weeks ^[13]. This process continues until all comments receive satisfactory responses.

Setting Initial Price Range

Companies release a preliminary prospectus after clearing SEC comments. This document, nicknamed a “red herring,” leaves out the final IPO price and share quantity ^[10]. Several factors influence the pricing:

• Feedback from book-building during roadshows
• Interest from institutional investors
• Market comparables
• Expected financial performance ^[10]

The roadshow runs for 7-10 trading days ^[14]. Management teams present to potential investors in multiple cities and countries. Underwriters collect feedback during this time to find the best price ^[10].

Opening Day Trading

Underwriters decide the final price with the company’s agreement the night before trading starts ^[10]. The next morning involves a price discovery process. This process is unique to exchanges like the NYSE, where Designated Market Makers (DMMs) run an auction to find the right opening price ^[15].

DMMs position themselves between buyers and sellers. They use price indications to show trading interest ^[15]. Trading officially begins once they reach a single price point ^[15].

Companies need enough funds throughout this timeline to cover transaction costs. Underwriting fees typically range between 4% to 7% of the gross IPO proceeds ^[16]. Public companies also spend between $1 million to $1.9 million yearly to maintain their public status ^[16].

Hidden Psychological Traps

Investors often make expensive mistakes in IPO markets because of psychological biases. Making rational investment choices requires you to learn about these hidden traps.

FOMO-Driven Investment Decisions

FOMO stands out as the biggest psychological trap in IPO investing. Research shows 51% of young investors between 18-40 put in more money than they planned just because of FOMO ^[17]. Social media makes this even worse. Young investors say platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube heavily influence 85% of their investment decisions ^[17].

Recent studies paint a worrying picture of FOMO-driven behavior. Most investors decide in less than a day, and 14% jump in within just an hour ^[18]. The market’s hype looks like a good sign to 63% of investors. Yet 40% of them end up regretting their hyped investment choices ^[18].

IPO markets make FOMO worse through:

• Quick profits from listing gains
• Extra market money fueling speculation
• More retail investors jumping in without homework ^[19]

Overconfidence in Hot IPOs

Male investors show more overconfidence than female and institutional investors in IPO markets ^[1]. This overconfidence makes investors:

• Think they know too much about market moves
• Miss obvious warning signs in financial reports
• Rush into decisions without proper research ^[4]

Overconfident investors usually:

• Ignore facts that don’t match their beliefs
• Keep taking bad advice from unreliable sources
• Stick with losing stocks because others do too ^[7]

Bull markets bring out investor’s greed and overconfidence. They’ll buy at any price ^[20]. Smart promoters time their IPOs during these bullish periods to get better valuations ^[20].

Behavioral finance experts point to these overconfidence warning signs:

• Believing good past returns guarantee future success
• Not paying attention to negative market signals
• Thinking they can predict market moves better than others ^[7]

Market data tells an interesting story. Strong IPO demand might create big day-one gains, but getting an allocation isn’t easy. This limits actual profit potential ^[19]. Many investors feel let down when the initial excitement fades and prices drop ^[20].

Smart investors can avoid these psychological traps by:

1. Setting clear investment rules before looking at any IPO
2. Finding different viewpoints to test their first impressions
3. Building long-term value instead of chasing quick profits ^[7]

Common Due Diligence Mistakes

Successful IPO investing depends on thorough due diligence. Many first-time investors miss key details that could affect their investment decisions.

Skipping the Prospectus Review

The prospectus is a vital document with everything about the company’s financial health, management, and business operations. SEC guidelines require this document to outline:

• Terms of securities being offered
• Company’s business model and strategy
• Financial statements and performance metrics
• Risk factors and potential challenges ^[21]

Many investors quickly scan or skip the prospectus completely. They miss significant details about how the company makes money, manages costs, and plans to stay profitable ^[2]. A complete review helps spot warning signs, especially about how IPO money will be used. Companies that want to use IPO funds to pay off debt might be under financial pressure ^[2].

Ignoring Lock-up Period Implications

Lock-up periods last between 90 to 180 days. During this time, company insiders and early investors can’t sell their shares ^[3]. Most investors don’t think over what happens when these restrictions end. Data shows that stock prices drop permanently by 1% to 3% after the lock-up period ends ^[3].

Stock performance after lock-up depends on:

• The number of restricted shares available
• Market timing and conditions
• Company’s performance since the IPO
• Insider confidence levels ^[22]

Research shows that share prices often fall even before the lock-up ends because investors expect more shares to flood the market ^[23]. Understanding lock-up terms helps create better investment strategies.

Missing Red Flags in Financial Statements

Between 2019-2023, all but one of these IPOs took place in their ‘home’ markets, which makes examining financial statements even more important ^[24]. Investors often miss:

The company’s profitability trends and cash flow patterns need careful review ^[25]. Too much insider selling might show lack of faith in the company’s future ^[25]. Weak corporate governance can hurt investor interests ^[25].

Recent market events prove these points. The grocery delivery service Instacart faced legal action from shareholders. Investors claimed it “negligently prepared documents” and misrepresented growth potential in its 2023 IPO ^[6]. Out of nearly 700 SPACs launched in 2021, 40% have already shut down ^[6].

Smart investors should review:

• The company’s financial health through statement analysis
• Market timing and economic conditions
• Post-IPO performance metrics and growth projections ^[26]

Positive returns aren’t guaranteed no matter the market conditions or company size. Success in IPO investments needs careful attention to detail ^[6].

Real Risk Assessment Framework

A solid risk assessment plan plays a vital role to assess IPO investments. Research that looked at market data from 1990 to 2000 shows that only 8% of IPOs showed both competitive value and fair market pricing ^[5].

Company Financial Health Checklist

The financial statements need a detailed review that covers revenue growth, profitability trends, and cash flow patterns. New investors should get into:

• Quarterly earnings reports as key indicators of financial health ^[27]
• Profit margins to understand operational efficiency ^[27]
• Cash flow from operations to assess sustainability ^[27]
• Earnings per share (EPS) growth relative to industry peers ^[27]

Underpricing remains the biggest problem. Historical data shows IPOs were underpriced by 11% between 1990-1998, and this jumped to 70% during 1999-2000 ^[5]. Companies left more than $60 billion on the table in 1999-2000 alone because of this underpricing ^[5].

Market Timing Factors

Market conditions shape how well IPOs perform. Studies show that trying to time the IPO market is risky, much like predicting stock index changes ^[28]. You need to think about:

• Market volatility indicators (VIX)
• Overall economic conditions
• Industry-specific trends
• Competitive landscape dynamics

The data reveals something interesting. Companies that showed strong performance against competitors after 30 days had less than a 20% first-day jump 74% of the time ^[5]. This shows why long-term value creation matters more than original price surges.

Post-IPO Performance Metrics

The first 30 days after listing need specific performance tracking ^[5]. These key metrics matter:

Market competitiveness shows through the company’s value compared to industry peers ^[5]. Research shows that all but one of these IPOs that looked highly successful based on first-day jumps would actually fail under this metric ^[5].

Market pricing stability comes from price changes between offering price and 30-day post-IPO market capitalization ^[5]. The best offerings typically vary less than 20% during this period ^[5].

Financial planning becomes more significant after the IPO. The focus moves from profit and loss statements to detailed balance sheet analysis ^[29]. Companies must forecast accurately because wrong projections can hurt investor confidence and share prices badly ^[29].

Conclusion

You need to look beyond surface-level analysis when investing in IPOs. Our research shows that successful IPO investing depends on several key elements – from proper due diligence to keeping your emotions in check.

Market data makes it clear – jumping into IPO investments because of hype or FOMO doesn’t work out well. First-day gains might look tempting, but your long-term success depends on how well you analyze financial statements, lock-up periods, and market timing.

Smart IPO investors stick to these vital practices:

• They read prospectus documents carefully
• They look past headline metrics to evaluate company financials
• They know what lock-up periods mean for their investment
• They stay calm despite market excitement
• They measure post-IPO success through solid metrics

History shows that companies continue to leave too much money on the table through underpricing. You need a well-laid-out risk assessment framework to protect your investment.

IPO investing works best when you balance solid research with practical risk management. IPOs can offer exciting opportunities, but note that all but one of these investments historically fail to deliver both competitive value and fair market pricing.

FAQs